Menus
Main Menu
Serving hours
Mon to Thurs...11 am to 10 pm
Fri to Sat...11 am to 12 am
Starters
-
Burrata & Prosciutto
$16Roasted tomatoes, arugula pesto, charred garlic bread
-
Believe You Me’s Wings
$15Grilled or fried, hot, mild, lemon pepper, cool ranch
-
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
$17Fresh horseradish, dijonnaise, cocktail sauce, lemon
-
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
$13Chorizo, maple & apple cider gastrique
-
Elote Dip
$12Warm and cheesy corn dip
Greens & Soup
-
Shaved Vegetable
$14Beets, radish, fennel, mixed greens, frisée, Banyuls vinaigrette, candied pecan
-
Baby Kale Caesar
$13Baby kale, little gem, parm, creamy Caesar, garlic breadcrumb, lemon zest
-
Gem Salad
$14Pickled shallot, goat cheese, radish, avocado, Green Goddess dressing
-
French Onion
$9Garlic crostini, Gruyère, crispy herbs
-
Chicken Velvet Soup
$9All the good veggies, basmati rice, pulled chicken
-
Add-Ons
Avocado $3
Chicken $5
Salmon $9
Steak $10
Chef’s Special
-
Hoosier State BPT Sliders
$13Thin tenderloin, pickles, lettuce, tomato, onion, dijonnaise
Sides
-
Whipped Potatoes
$6 -
Hand Cut Fries
$5 -
Onion Straws
$6 -
Charred Broccolini
$7 -
Side Salad
$5
Sandwiches
Served with garden salad or hand cut fries-
Prime Rib Sando
$21Charred garlic baguette, au jus, Swiss, horseradish aioli
-
Truffled Grilled Cheese
$15Cheddar, Havarti, black truffle, sourdough
-
Cardinal Burger
$17Double wagyu patties, dijonnaise, pickles, red onion, sharp American
-
Turkey Club
$14House smoked turkey, thick bacon, butter lettuce, plum tomato, Green Goddess mayo
-
Crispy Chicken Sando
$13Buttermilk brined chicken, Green Goddess ranch, pickles
Dessert
-
Proper Ice Cream Sundae
$6Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, all the things
-
Key Lime Pie
$7Candied citrus, whipped cream
-
Mary B’s Apple Crisp
$7 -
Chocolate Ice Box Pie
$7 -
Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies
$5 -
Scoop of Sorbet or Ice Cream
$4
Specials Menu
-
Fish & Chips
$22Beer battered cod filet, crispy fries, malt aioli
-
Stuffed Peppers
$21Squash, zucchini, eggplant, rice, herbs, marinara
-
Pot Roast
$24Glazed carrots, whipped potatoes, herb gravy
-
Chicken Pot Pie
$28Pulled chicken, peas, carrots, potato, puff pastry
-
Mac N Cheese
$19Ooey-gooey, parmesan bread crumb
Add Chorizo $5
Add Shrimp $8
-
New York Strip
$34Charred New York strip, steak salt, roasted garlic butter
-
Breaded Pork Chop
$25Arugula, shaved fennel, lemon, grain mustard, remoulade